A Possible New Compton Effect

Amazingly little actual knowledge exists regarding the extreme remote Universe. In general, bits and pieces of data are known, and those small amounts of information have been rather broadly expanded by various assumptions. The primary problem is that there is no apparent way to confirm or deny the validity of most of those assumptions.

Certain of those assumptions seem reasonably sound. The idea that the Law of Gravitation applies equally everywhere in the Universe seems reasonable. The idea that the speed of light and other known constants such as PI and e and h are invariable also seem logical.

However, there is a well known phenomenon that might make certain of these constants appear as though they might have slightly different values. It is called the Compton Effect. It is well documented that there are some experiments where a photon interacts with an electron, and manages to impart some kinetic energy to the electron. The photon that then leaves the area has less total energy, which means that it is redder in color than before it interacted with the electron.

Virtually all objects that astrophysics believes to be very distant, have very large red shifts. The standard understanding of this red shift is that it is entirely due to the Doppler Effect, where a light source that is moving away from us has fewer wavefronts getting to us each second, which therefore also causes a red shift. The Doppler Shift is so universally accepted as the cause of the red shift seen in all distant object that the phrases "Red Shift" and "Doppler Shift" are often used almost interchangeably.

The point of this essay is to suggest that there are a number of other possible sources for a red shift seen in stars' spectra. Something like the Compton Effect is worthy of consideration. So are other possibilities.

The general premise is that, in a light path that might be billions of light-years long, a lot of unrecognized things might happen! In empty space, there are not a lot of atoms and electrons, but in a path-length of billions of light years long, a photon might happen to encounter one. If it's interaction with an electron was such that a Compton Effect occurred, the continuing photon would have less energy, and therefore appear to be red-shifted.

In the case of the Compton Effect, it would be tough to present a persuasive argument though, regarding galactic red shifts. A Compton Effect encounter involves a single photon. If it had arisen from glowing Hydrogen, it would likely have a frequency of one of the Balmer series of Hydrogen spectrum lines. NOT any of the other Balmer lines! So, a single Compton Effect encounter might shift one of the lines of the Hydrogen spectrum by some red-shift, but the rest of the lines would not then be shifted. THAT would not explain it.

It would be more likely to have to conclude that there were MANY Compton Effect like encounters along the way, so many that statistical analysis would apply. That seems to be the only way where all of the various spectral lines would thus be shifted by similar amounts. There are assorted theoretical problems in such multitudes of small shifts, particularly the alteration regarding the direction of the propagation of the photons. They would probably then no longer seem to have come from a single source.


The main point of this essay is not really to "promote" the Compton Effect as THE explanation for all the large red shifts that are seen in apparently distant objects, but rather to suggest that there may be assorted alternate concepts worth considering. Yes, the Doppler Effect is probably the most significant effect regarding red shifts, but other effects might wind up having significant effect, too.

A specific example is an apparent consequence of relativity's time dilation. It is commonly accepted that a rapidly receding (or approaching) astronaut in a spacecraft would age more slowly than his twin brother left back on Earth, because of the effect of time dilation. If we had a strong enough telescope to see him, he would appear to be moving in slow motion! Now say that he had a container of glowing hydrogen in his spacecraft. The motion of those atoms of hydrogen would also seem to us to be moving more slowly, for the same time dilation reason. The result would be that the oscillation frequency of the hydrogen atoms would appear to be lower, which would appear to be a red shift to us.

This same effect should exist in any glowing star that is receding at relativistic velocities. In some cases, the red shift caused by this Time Dilation Effect is as much as 1/3 the size of the Relativistic Doppler Effect. An implication is that "real" Doppler shifts for very distant objects might only be 3/4 as great as previously thought. That would indicate that such objects are actually much closer than previously thought and they were receding as less velocity. These are huge implications, which could reflect on the scale of the Universe and many other things. I wrote a separate presentation on that subject, which is at:
http://mb-soft.com/public/reltvty2.html


This presentation was first placed on the Internet in March 2003.



Links to advanced-physics-related pages in this Domain:
A logical, fully Newtonian explanation for Galaxy Arm persistence
A more correct presentation of the Relativity Twins Paradox story
A careful analysis of NIST data suggests that neutrons do not exist within the nucleus of atoms
A clear violation to the Conservation of Angular Momentum
The Quantum Defect is entirely different than generally assumed, and is calculated here
The NIST atomic Ionization published data suggests serious flaws in a basic statement of nuclear physics
Clear flaws in some basic assumptions of Nuclear Physics
Gravitational Theory and Resonance
A logic-based theory for the Earth's formation
An improved theory for the source of the complex Earth's Magnetic Field
IF there is an immense number of neutrinos, where did they come from?
Experiments to detect Neutrinos should not work as assumed!
A huge possible energy supply from the rotation of the Earth
An important gravitational experiment

Problems with the tilt of the Sun's rotation, etc
A presentation of the physics of gyroscopic precession
An alternative concept to what is called the Big Bang
A problem with the claim of extreme age for Globular Clusters
A potential Hubble telescope experiment to confirm the quantum nature of energy
A careful discussion on the Origin of the Moon
Friction should have slowed the rotation of Jupiter, Saturn, etc iver billions of years
A discussion on radioactive age dating methods
An analysis of data available from Cepheid variable stars
A possible new Compton Effect


Link to the Index of these Public Service Pages

( http://mb-soft.com/public/index.html )



E-mail to: Public1@mb-soft.com

C Johnson, Physicist, Physics Degree from Univ of Chicago