HERE is where the great concern is regarding Genetically Modified foods and the rest. Imagine some wealthy parent who will insist on his coming child having blue eyes. And some laboratory will be willing to take his $300,000 to try to do it. What if WE DON'T KNOW YET that 29 letters down your DNA is the nucleotide which determines whether that baby will get Downes Syndrome or Leprosy or a thousand other maladies. And the researcher who found the section of DNA that contained the BLUE nucleotide did not realize that the chunk of DNA that he was able to separate away happened to include that Leprosy nucleotide. So the baby is born, and it HAS blue eyes, but a few years later it will die of Leprosy! NOT from any intentional action, but just the ignorance of not having any idea what MOST of the letters of our DNA actually are for.
|
That chunk commonly contains thousands of nucleotides which just happen to be near the one he wants to change. Now, when his experiment is done, and he sees that he DID cause the change in that plant or animal that he had wished, it is again not nearly as impressive as the public is led to believe. He does a THOUSAND similar experiments, each chopping out SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT chunks and replacing them with slightly different chunks. He examines ALL his thousand experiments and finds that ONE of those experiments has the desired changes in the plant or animal. He actually does NOT know WHICH of his thousand experiments resulted in that desired change, and he also does NOT know why the other 999 experiments failed to give the desired change. So he is to a great extent, in the dark! He does NOT know what any of the other nucleotides near his target one do. When some of the experiments are terminal failures, where the plant or animal dies, he learns that there is something nearby that may be bad. But he never knows WHICH nucleotide, and essentially does not care that much about it, as long as his successful experiment provided the result that will make him rich and famous! Not much else matters!
Tomatoes and sweet corn and every other fruit and vegetable have DNA that is comparably as complex as ours is. Do you really believe that thousands of researchers spent 20 years in making absolutely sure that there was no possible down-side regarding ACCIDENTALLY altering a nucleotide that happened to be near one they want to replace in a tomato? Not a chance! Once they did thousands of recombinant-DNA experiments and found that ONE of the experiments resulted in a tomato that had a prettier skin or a tougher skin, yes, they probably did do LIMITED safety testing to try to confirm that their new tomato did not cause people to die who ate them. But what if they had accidentally replaced a perfectly safe natural nucleotide with one that caused Dengue Fever or Ebola? There is NO independent safety group or government agency that ever confirms the safety of the results of their very secret experiments. THOSE researchers write up their own report regarding whatever safety testing they claim to have done and NO ONE IS EVER IN ANY POSITION TO CONFIRM OR DENY their statements! Given that those researchers each KNOW that they WILL become multi-millionaires if a GM fruit or vegetable that he or she created becomes sold to millions of farmers. There is tremendous incentive to avoid saying anything which might hurt the chance of those millions of dollars. And great incentive to present their creation as perfect and magical.
Again, that would be great if it were actually to turn out to be true. But the fact that those researchers cannot possibly totally know what even 1% of the DNA of their fruit or vegetable is actually for, it results in a remarkably terrifying experiment where we, the public, are the guinea pigs. And the immense scale of the usage of GM fruits and vegetables pretty much means that when some major disaster will happen (and it certainly will), and millions of victims around the world discover that they have some deadly malady they got from eating the GM fruit or vegetable, there will NOT be any way to go back! One of the first things that the chemical companies insisted on is that their fruits and vegetables have DNA which is altered so that they cannot reproduce. That way the companies can be sure that no one can plant anything next year without having to buy new seeds from them, pure profit! The vast majority of seeds used by all farmers around the world are now GM seeds. That means that there are essentially NO REMAINING NATURAL SEEDS which could ever be used in the future, just in case we ever needed them.
Public Service Categories |
Self-Sufficiency - Many Suggestions Environmental Subjects Scientific Subjects Advanced Physics Social Subjects Religious Subjects Public Services Home Page Main Menu |
That single statement made clear that the HEALTH AND SAFETY of the American Public was not seen as important, while the ability of giant corporations to be able to make billions of dollars of profits is.
The very same giant chemical corporations had previously proven that they had been in too much of a hurry to get profitable products out to market. An obvious example was DDT, which was sold massively on the market for decades before it was discovered that the DDT had the direct effect of exterminating many animals and fish, and it was removed from the market. They also created and promoted Agent Orange during the Vietnam War, which caused GENETIC DEFECTS in countless thousands of people who were exposed to that chemical (and it was then removed from usage). The same giant chemical corporations invented Dioxins and quickly began to use them broadly, only to discover again after decades that their (relatively untested) chemical had also caused genetic flaws in thousands of Americans, along with permanently contaminating and polluting lands and streams.
More significant here is that, even in 2010 after ten years of thousands of researchers carefully studying the Human Genome, NO ONE YET KNOWS HOW MANY GENES WE ACTUALLY HAVE! Current ESTIMATES range between 20,000 and 25,000! Most best guesses today are in the 22,000 to 23,000 range. NOT AN EXACT NUMBER.
The public is given the impression that Genetic Modification is a field where the science is fully advanced. The very fact that no one even yet knows HOW MANY genes we have, should be a clue of how primitive our understanding yet is regarding these fields.
It may be another twenty years before MOST of the human genes are identified relatively accurately. Yes, INDIVIDUAL genes are identified, as having to do with some terrible disease or with eye color or hair color or other simple effects, and such findings always get into the Evening News. But as of 2010, there are still more than 20,000 genes in human physiology which we do NOT have any clue about!
What ACTUALLY is done in such research is to cause chromosomes to be ripped apart AT SOME UNKNOWN LOCATION (which could only be identified LATER by an electron microscope or similar equipment).
So then when a researcher decides to SPLICE two parts of (copies of) a chromosome, IT IS REALLY VIRTUALLY ENTIRELY PURE CHANCE what might get formed. Most of the results are incapable of surviving. Only a very small fraction of such experiments result in a spliced chromosome which actually has the ability to function.
And the RESULTS of such a gene splicing are generally NEVER KNOWN until that modified chromosome is inserted into some test animal or plant (chromosomes ARE large enough to see in a powerful microscope) and that organism is grown to see what might have changed.
IN OTHER WORDS, virtually all such experiments which attempt to modify genes are done in effective total darkness, where no results are known UNTIL much later when an animal does something like glowing in the dark. THAT was the evidence that the "glowing gene" from one plant or animal had been grafted into the chromosome of the target animal (and the animal survived).
No one outside that corporate laboratory would ever be allowed to see such a tomato or to test the safety of it. Only employees of that same laboratory would be able to do that. And if no disastrous side effects were discovered, such a genetically modified tomato would soon be sold to farmers and planted, and the public would soon be eating a food which contains an amazingly large number of unknown factors in it.
Public Service Categories |
Self-Sufficiency - Many Suggestions Environmental Subjects Scientific Subjects Advanced Physics Social Subjects Religious Subjects Public Services Home Page Main Menu |
But DDT was a SIMPLE chemical! DNA is not!
This page - -
- - is at
This subject presentation was last updated on - -
index.html
index.html
C Johnson, Theoretical Physicist, Physics Degree from Univ of Chicago